Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Susie Mawhinney's avatar

I have been trying to compose a reply to this powerfully thought provoking essay for most of the day, I’ve read it twice and even while walking when most of the words I am searching for almost always flow into an order I am pleased with, nothing was seeping through. I’ve tried to finish a letter of my own… but still nothing. It happens, I guess, to us all.

Then I read this - included in something I’m working on… somehow it touched one of the many nuances I found in your words… that of language/understanding between animal and human….

‘Magic Words after Nalungiaq’

In the very earliest time,
when both people and animals lived on earth,
a person could become an animal if he wanted to
and an animal could become a human being.
Sometimes they were people
and sometimes animals
and there was no difference.
All spoke the same language.
That was the time when words were like magic.
The human mind had mysterious powers.
A word spoken by chance
might have strange consequences.
It would suddenly come alive
and what people wanted to happen could happen —
all you had to do was say it.
Nobody could explain this:
That’s the way it was.

(Translated from the Inuit by Edward Field)

I’d like to think, in this undeniably pivotal moment, that the way it was, will be the way again - a symbolic symbiotic migration towards deeper human understanding, not only of animals but all of nature.

I’m still in deep contemplation Jonathan, your intricately clever essay won’t leave me in peace…

Expand full comment
Fotini Masika's avatar

I was never into billiard but according to your line of thought I'm striking balls all the time. Helpless :)

Most of the time I feel that every moment is a pivotal moment and our life is a series of pivotal moments, each one so close to the other that we're under the illusion we're following a line. But I think your closing words depict much better our state in this life -- arms flailing in a frothy soup.

Thank you for this thought provoking / emotional bubbling post, Jonathan, I need to re-read this.

Expand full comment
35 more comments...

No posts